Payroll is the Friday problem every small HVAC company knows. The crew worked long hours on an install week, one tech did a Saturday callout, and the pay run still has to be right. A payroll tool for this trade is judged on overtime, pay rates, seasonal hires, and 1099 subcontractors.
Gusto Simple costs 79 dollars a month for 5 staff. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs 82 dollars and 50 cents a month. The gap is only 3 dollars and 50 cents a month. The real difference is local tax filing, the accounting subscription, and time tracking. This guide works through those differences for one exact team, an owner plus 4 techs.
Quick verdict
- Best for this exact team: Gusto Simple. At 79 dollars a month for 5 staff, with unlimited pay runs and federal, state and local tax filing on every plan.
- Best if the crew works across state lines or hires often: Gusto Plus. At 140 dollars a month for 5 staff, with multi-state payroll, time tracking and hiring tools.
- Best if the books already live in QuickBooks Online: QuickBooks Workforce Payroll. At 82 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff before accounting.
The team in this guide: owner plus 4 techs
Every number here assumes the same team: an owner plus 4 techs in a small HVAC company. The owner runs the office between jobs, answers the phone on busy mornings, and signs off the pay run on Friday. There is no separate office staff and no full-time dispatcher.
Pay runs weekly or biweekly, and the hours are never flat. Install weeks push techs past 40 hours, Saturday callouts add a callout rate, and summer brings a seasonal hire and a 1099 subcontractor for install help. Our best software for HVAC companies roundup covers the job tools that sit beside payroll for this team.
Gusto prices, tier by tier
Gusto sells three plans, priced as a monthly base fee plus a per-person fee. Every plan is month-to-month with no long-term contract. Every plan includes unlimited pay runs.
| Plan | Monthly base | Per person | Cost for 5 staff | Cost for 10 staff |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto Simple | $49 | $6 | $79 a month | $109 a month |
| Gusto Plus | $80 | $12 | $140 a month | $200 a month |
| Gusto Premium | $180 | $22 | $290 a month | $400 a month |
Simple, at 49 dollars a month plus 6 dollars per person. Gusto files federal, state and local payroll tax forms on every plan, so the single-state line is the only real limit.
Plus, at 80 dollars a month plus 12 dollars per person. Plus adds multi-state payroll, time tracking and scheduling, hiring tools and unlimited next-day bank pay.
Premium, at 180 dollars a month plus 22 dollars per person. Premium adds HR help and a named account partner. Gusto repackaged its plans on 1 October 2026 without changing the prices above, and its Contractor Only plan closed to new signups on the same date. No free trial is named on the pricing page.
QuickBooks prices, tier by tier
QuickBooks Payroll was renamed QuickBooks Workforce in July 2026. Workforce Payroll costs 50 dollars a month plus 6 dollars and 50 cents per person, Workforce Premium costs 88 dollars a month plus 10 dollars per person, and Workforce Elite costs 134 dollars a month plus 12 dollars per person. Intuit sells payroll bundled with a QuickBooks Online accounting plan, so a new buyer prices the pair.
| Plan | Monthly base | Per person | Cost for 5 staff | Cost for 10 staff |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Workforce Payroll | $50 | $6.50 | $82.50 a month | $115 a month |
| Workforce Premium | $88 | $10 | $138 a month | $188 a month |
| Workforce Elite | $134 | $12 | $194 a month | $254 a month |
| Workforce Payroll with Simple Start | $88 | $6.50 | $120.50 a month | $153 a month |
Workforce Payroll, at 50 dollars a month plus 6 dollars and 50 cents per person. The entry tier includes next-day bank pay, auto payroll, full-service tax filing and 1099 e-filing. The honest limit sits in the tax line: the entry tier does not file local taxes, so a crew in a city with a local payroll tax needs Premium.
Workforce Premium, at 88 dollars a month plus 10 dollars per person. Premium steps up to same-day bank pay, time tracking, an HR support center and workers comp admin. The jump from Workforce Payroll to Premium costs 55 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff.
Workforce Elite, at 134 dollars a month plus 12 dollars per person. Elite adds project tracking, a personal HR advisor and tax penalty protection up to 25,000 dollars a year.
Worked yearly cost for the 5-person HVAC company
Gusto Simple costs 79 dollars a month for 5 staff, or 948 dollars over twelve months. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs 82 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff, or 990 dollars over twelve months. The gap is 3 dollars and 50 cents a month.
The gap opens once the accounting subscription is added. Workforce Payroll bought with Simple Start lists at 120 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff, or 1,446 dollars over twelve months. That is 41 dollars and 50 cents a month more than Gusto Simple, or 498 dollars more over a year. A company whose books already live in QuickBooks Online pays no extra accounting cost for that pair, while a company that does not use QuickBooks Online pays it in full, every month, all year.
Side by side: what each tool covers for 5 people
| Question | Gusto | QuickBooks Workforce |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price for 5 staff | Simple, 79 dollars a month | Workforce Payroll, 82 dollars and 50 cents a month before accounting |
| Entry price with accounting | No accounting subscription needed | 120 dollars and 50 cents a month |
| Yearly cost for 5 staff | Simple 948, Plus 1,680, Premium 3,480 dollars | Payroll 990, Premium 1,656, Elite 2,328 dollars, before accounting |
| Pay runs | Unlimited pay runs on every plan | Auto payroll on every tier |
| Tax filing | Federal, state and local forms on every plan | Full-service filing, entry tier does not file local taxes |
| Time tracking | Plus and above | Premium and above |
| Bank pay speed | Next-day on Plus, same-day as a paid add-on | Next-day bank pay on every tier, same-day from Premium |
| 1099 subcontractors | Billed only in months they are paid | 1099 e-filing included |
| Multi-state payroll | Plus and above, Simple is single-state | Not named on the pricing page |
| Free trial | No free trial named on the pricing page | 30-day free trial |
| Best fit | Single-state crew that wants local tax filing | Company whose books already live in QuickBooks Online |
Overtime and multiple pay rates
Gusto puts time tracking and scheduling on Plus, at 140 dollars a month for 5 staff. A company on Plus tracks hours in the same place it runs payroll. That is where an install week with three pay rates is caught cleanly: install, repair and Saturday callout hours at three rates. See our best scheduling software for HVAC companies guide.
QuickBooks puts time tracking on Premium, at 138 dollars a month for 5 staff before accounting, with the payroll AI flag on odd hours before the run. The two middle tiers cost almost the same, so the overtime choice is a system choice, not a price choice.
Seasonal and on-call pay
Gusto handles the seasonal shape through its per-person billing. Contractors are billed only in months they are paid, so a subcontractor who helps on installs in June and does nothing in January costs nothing in January. A seasonal W-2 hire adds 6 dollars a month on Simple or 12 dollars a month on Plus while on the roster.
A quiet January still bills the base fee on both tools, so the seasonal saving comes from the per-person fee, not the base fee, and a crew that pauses hiring in winter should count that base fee as a fixed cost.
QuickBooks handles the seasonal shape the same way on the payroll side. The seasonal cost that does not shrink on QuickBooks is the accounting subscription beside payroll. It keeps billing all year even in a quiet month. A company that buys the pair only for payroll pays for accounting through the slow season too.
1099 subcontractors, paid next to W-2 staff
Most small HVAC companies run W-2 staff and 1099 subcontractors side by side, and the mix changes with the job list. A busy install month brings a subcontractor in for extra hands. The payroll tool has to pay both groups in the same pay run and file the year-end forms without the owner chasing paperwork in January. Our best CRM for HVAC companies guide covers how those install jobs are tracked before they reach the pay run.
Gusto treats a contractor as a person who is billed only when paid. A subcontractor who works two install weeks in June is billed at the per-person rate for June only. The Contractor Only plan is closed to new signups since 1 October 2026.
QuickBooks treats a contractor through 1099 e-filing, included on Workforce Payroll. The contractor-only option at 15 dollars for 20 contractors plus 2 dollars per extra contractor is the flat route for a company with a long sub list. Gusto wins the occasional-sub shape, while QuickBooks wins the many-sub shape. Confirm with your accountant whether a worker is W-2 staff or a 1099 subcontractor.
Tax filing: the line that splits the cheapest tier from the honest one
Tax filing is the line that splits the cheapest plan from the honest one, and it is where Gusto pulls clear for this team. Gusto files federal, state and local payroll tax forms on every plan, including Simple at 79 dollars a month for 5 staff. One missed local filing costs far more than a year of that 3 dollars and 50 cents a month gap.
QuickBooks files federal and state taxes on Workforce Payroll, but the entry tier does not file local taxes. A crew in a city with a local payroll tax needs Premium, at 138 dollars a month for 5 staff before accounting, to get local filing. Neither tool replaces professional advice on worker classification, state registration or year-end planning, so confirm tax details with your accountant.
Time tracking: where the hours are caught
Gusto Plus adds time tracking and scheduling at 140 dollars a month for 5 staff. Hours tracked in Gusto flow into the pay run in the same system.
QuickBooks Premium adds time tracking at 138 dollars a month for 5 staff before accounting, plus an HR support center and workers comp admin. The payroll AI flags odd hours before the run. That flag is the feature to weigh: on an install week when one tech logs 20 hours more than the rest, the flag catches the error before the money moves.
The QuickBooks ledger link: the one reason to pay more
The QuickBooks ledger link is the one reason to pay more for QuickBooks Workforce, and it is a strong reason for the right company. Every pay run posts straight into QuickBooks Online. Our best invoicing software for HVAC companies guide covers the customer invoice side of that same ledger, so the pay run and the invoice stay in step.
That link is worth the bundle price only when the books already live in QuickBooks Online. A company that already runs its accounting there pays 82 dollars and 50 cents a month for Workforce Payroll, and the pay run simply appears in the ledger it already checks. A company that does not use QuickBooks Online pays 120 dollars and 50 cents a month for the pair with Simple Start, or 498 dollars a year more than Gusto Simple. Gusto has no accounting ledger of its own. Judge the ledger link by counting the Friday-night job it removes: if the owner spends an hour a week posting payroll into the books, the link saves that hour.
Trials: what is known, and what is still to come
QuickBooks offers a 30-day free trial, or 50 percent off base fees for 3 months instead. A 5-person HVAC company can run real pay runs through the trial and judge whether Workforce Payroll or Premium fits daily work, before paying anything. The trial tests fit, not cost, because the prices are published.
Gusto names no free trial on its pricing page, so the route in is a month-to-month signup with no long-term contract. Trial walkthroughs for both tools are still to come, so no hands-on claim is made here. For the full roundup, see our best payroll software for small contractors guide.
Who should pick what
Pick Gusto Simple first if you run an owner plus 4 techs in one state: Simple at 79 dollars a month for 5 staff, with local tax filing on the cheapest tier.
Pick Gusto Plus first if your crew works across state lines, hires often, or needs time tracking in payroll: Plus at 140 dollars a month for 5 staff.
Pick QuickBooks Workforce Payroll first if your books already live in QuickBooks Online: Workforce Payroll at 82 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff before accounting, with every pay run posting straight into the ledger.
Pick QuickBooks Workforce Premium first if your crew is in a city with a local payroll tax, or needs same-day bank pay and time tracking in one tier: Premium at 138 dollars a month for 5 staff.
Do not buy Gusto Premium early if the team is still at 5 people: at 290 dollars a month, price Plus first.
Honest limits of this comparison
- This comparison rests on the official pricing pages of Gusto and QuickBooks, checked on 8 November 2026, not on hands-on use. Our own trial test is still to come.
- Neither tool is HVAC specific, and neither names job costing, prevailing-wage tracking or certified payroll reporting on its pricing page, so a crew that needs those features should test for them.
- QuickBooks payroll is sold with a QuickBooks Online accounting plan, so the 50 dollar a month headline is not the whole bill for a new buyer. Workforce Payroll does not file local taxes, so a city crew needs Premium.
- Gusto same-day bank pay is a paid add-on per pay run, not part of any tier, and no price for that add-on is stated here.
- Payroll tax rules change by state and by job. Confirm tax details with your accountant.
The verdict
For a 5-person HVAC company, an owner plus 4 techs, Gusto Simple is the better pick, because it costs 79 dollars a month for 5 staff, it files federal, state and local payroll tax forms on the cheapest tier, and it needs no accounting subscription beside it. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs almost the same on payroll alone, but the pair with Simple Start costs 120 dollars and 50 cents a month, and the entry tier does not file local taxes. QuickBooks earns its place only when the company books already live in QuickBooks Online.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for a small HVAC company, Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll?
For a 5-person HVAC company, Gusto Simple is the better pick. It costs 79 dollars a month for 5 staff, it files federal, state and local payroll tax forms on every plan, and it needs no accounting subscription beside it. QuickBooks Workforce wins only when the company books already live in QuickBooks Online.
How much does Gusto cost for a 5-person HVAC company?
Gusto Simple costs 79 dollars a month for 5 staff, or 948 dollars over twelve months. Gusto Plus costs 140 dollars a month for 5 staff, or 1,680 dollars over twelve months. Gusto Premium costs 290 dollars a month for 5 staff, or 3,480 dollars over twelve months.
How much does QuickBooks Payroll cost for a 5-person HVAC company?
QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs 82 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff, or 990 dollars over twelve months, before any accounting subscription. Bought with Simple Start, the pair lists at 120 dollars and 50 cents a month for 5 staff, or 1,446 dollars over twelve months. Workforce Premium costs 138 dollars a month for 5 staff.
Can a small HVAC company try Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll before buying?
QuickBooks offers a 30-day free trial, or 50 percent off base fees for 3 months. Gusto names no free trial on its pricing page, so the route in is a month-to-month signup. Our own trial test of both tools is still to come.
Prices verified on the official pricing pages of Gusto and QuickBooks on 8 November 2026.
Related reading: our best payroll software for small contractors guide, our best software for HVAC companies roundup, our best CRM for HVAC companies guide, our best scheduling software for HVAC companies guide, and our best invoicing software for HVAC companies guide.
