Payroll is the Friday problem every small contractor knows. The crew worked long hours, one tech did a Saturday callout, and the pay run still has to be right. A payroll tool for this trade is judged on the things office software never thinks about: weekly or biweekly pay, overtime that changes every week, different pay rates for different jobs, seasonal hires who vanish in winter, and 1099 subcontractors paid next to W-2 staff.
Quick verdict
- Best overall for a small contractor: Square Payroll at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. Overtime calculations, multistate payroll, unlimited pay runs, next-day bank pay and a free seasonal pause come in one plan.
- Best budget pick: Patriot Full Service at $37 a month plus $5 per worker paid. For a 5-person crew it costs $62 a month, the lowest monthly cost here for payroll with tax filing done for you.
- Best for a multi-state crew that hires often: Gusto Plus at $80 a month plus $12 per person. Multi-state payroll, time tracking and hiring tools sit on one tier, and contractors are billed only in months they are paid.
- Best if your books already live in QuickBooks Online: QuickBooks Workforce Payroll at $50 a month plus $6.50 per person. Pay runs post straight into the ledger, but payroll is sold with an accounting plan, so budget the pair, not the headline.
How a small contractor should choose payroll software
Start with the pay run itself, because that is where contractor payroll breaks. Field crews are paid weekly or biweekly, hours swing with the job list, and overtime is normal, not rare. A tool earns its place here when it handles multiple pay rates for one worker, calculates overtime without a spreadsheet on the side, and runs an off-cycle payment when a job ends midweek. Square Payroll names overtime calculations and multiple pay rates on its full-service plan, Patriot lets one worker hold up to 25 pay rates, Gusto Plus adds time tracking on the same tier, and QuickBooks puts time tracking on Premium.
The second test is the mix of people on the payroll. Most small contractors run W-2 staff and 1099 subcontractors side by side, and the mix changes with the season. Gusto bills contractors only in months they are paid, Square and Patriot charge per person paid, not per person on the roster, so a quiet month costs less. Square adds a free seasonal pause, so a landscaping crew can stop paying the base fee in the off-season. Patriot pays contractors inside payroll on both plans, and QuickBooks sells a contractor-only option at $15 for 20 contractors plus $2 per extra contractor.
The last test is tax filing, and it is the line that splits the cheapest plan from the honest one. Full-service plans file and pay federal, state and local payroll taxes for you. Patriot Basic does not file taxes at all, so the $17 a month headline is only honest if you file yourself. Workforce Payroll files federal and state taxes but not local taxes, which matters in cities with a local payroll tax. Gusto files federal, state and local forms on every plan.
The four tools at a glance
Entry prices run from $17 a month to $50 a month before the per-person fee.
| Tool | Entry price | What a contractor gets | Free trial |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto | Simple, $49 a month plus $6 per person. Plus, $80 plus $12. Premium, $180 plus $22 | Unlimited pay runs and tax filing on every plan, time tracking and multi-state payroll from Plus, contractors billed only in months paid | No free trial named on the pricing page. Month-to-month, cancel anytime |
| QuickBooks Workforce | Workforce Payroll, $50 a month plus $6.50 per person. Premium, $88 plus $10. Elite, $134 plus $12 | Next-day bank pay on every tier, same-day bank pay and time tracking from Premium, tax penalty protection on Elite | 30-day free trial, or 50 percent off base fees for 3 months |
| Square Payroll | Full-service, $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. Contractor-only, $6 per person paid | Unlimited pay runs, overtime calculations, multiple pay rates, multistate payroll, auto payroll, free seasonal pause, timecard import from Square tools | No free trial named on the pricing page. No long-term contract |
| Patriot Software | Basic Payroll, $17 a month plus $4 per worker paid. Full Service, $37 plus $5 per worker paid | Unlimited payrolls on both plans, free bank pay, up to 25 pay rates per worker, tax filing and year-end forms on Full Service only | 30 days free, then 50 percent off for 3 months |
See our best software for plumbing businesses roundup for the job tools that sit beside payroll.
Gusto: the best-known payroll name, with a clear tier ladder
Gusto is the best-known payroll name here, and its pricing page is the clearest of the four: a monthly base fee plus a per-person fee on every plan. Simple costs $49 a month plus $6 per person, Plus costs $80 a month plus $12 per person, and Premium costs $180 a month plus $22 per person. Every plan is month-to-month with no long-term contract, and every plan includes unlimited pay runs. Contractors are billed at the per-person rate only in months when they are paid.
Simple is built for a single-state crew that wants payroll and tax filing done right. Gusto files federal, state and local payroll tax forms on your behalf. The limit for a contractor is the single-state line: a crew that works across state lines outgrows Simple fast. Plus is the tier that fits most growing contracting crews, because it adds multi-state payroll, time tracking and scheduling, contractor invoice management, hiring tools and unlimited next-day bank pay. Premium adds a named account partner, HR guidance and tools, and compliance help, at a price that suits a larger crew.
Gusto repackaged its plans on 1 October 2026 without changing the prices above, and its Contractor Only plan closed to new signups on the same date. Same-day bank pay is a paid add-on per pay run, not part of any tier.
Best for: a growing crew that works across state lines and wants time tracking and hiring on the same tier. Skip it if: your crew is small, single-state and seasonal, because Square or Patriot costs less.
QuickBooks Workforce: payroll that lives inside your books
QuickBooks Payroll was renamed QuickBooks Workforce in July 2026, and its prices were restructured on the same date. The three tiers are Workforce Payroll at $50 a month plus $6.50 per person, Workforce Premium at $88 a month plus $10 per person, and Workforce Elite at $134 a month plus $12 per person. Intuit now sells payroll bundled with a QuickBooks Online accounting plan, so a new buyer prices the pair: Workforce Payroll with Simple Start lists at $88 a month plus $6.50 per person. A 30-day free trial is offered, or 50 percent off base fees for 3 months.
The reason to pay the higher entry price is the ledger. Every pay run posts straight into QuickBooks Online without exports or mapping, and its payroll AI flags odd hours before the run. Workforce Payroll includes next-day bank pay, auto payroll, full-service tax filing and 1099 e-filing. Premium steps up to same-day bank pay, time tracking, an HR support center and workers comp admin, the tier an hourly field crew needs. Elite adds project tracking, a personal HR advisor and tax penalty protection up to $25,000 a year.
The honest limits are the bundle and the local tax gap. Payroll is a separate subscription on top of accounting, so the $50 a month headline is never the whole bill for a new buyer. The entry tier does not file local taxes, so a crew in a city with a local payroll tax needs Premium. The contractor-only option is $15 for 20 contractors plus $2 per extra contractor.
Best for: a contractor whose books already live in QuickBooks Online and who wants pay runs inside the ledger. Skip it if: you do not use QuickBooks Online, because the accounting subscription is a cost the other three tools do not carry.
Square Payroll: the cheapest full-service start, built for hourly crews
Square Payroll is the cheapest full-service option in this guide, and its pricing page is the shortest: full-service payroll costs $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, and contractor-only payroll costs $6 per person paid. There are no tiers to climb and no long-term contract, and the per-person fee is charged per person paid, so a month with a smaller crew costs less, and a free seasonal pause lets a business stop paying in the off-season.
For a contractor, the feature list reads like it was written for hourly field work. Unlimited pay runs, auto payroll, off-cycle payments, multiple pay rates, overtime calculations, timecard import from Square POS and the Square Team App, and multistate payroll are all included on the one full-service plan. Pay runs can pay by check, by bank pay or through Cash App, with two-day and four-day bank pay and next-day bank pay included. Automated federal and state tax payments and filings are included.
The limits sit at the edges of the Square world. Time tracking and scheduling live inside Square tools, so a crew that tracks hours elsewhere must import timecards or switch systems. Same-day bank pay is not named on the pricing page.
Best for: a small hourly crew that wants the lowest full-service bill with overtime and seasonal flexibility. Skip it if: you need same-day bank pay, or your time tracking lives in another system you will not move.
Patriot Software: the lowest monthly bill for filed taxes
Patriot Software publishes the lowest prices in this guide, and its pricing page prints them plainly: Basic Payroll costs $17 a month plus $4 per worker paid, and Full Service Payroll costs $37 a month plus $5 per worker paid. A current offer gives 30 days free, then 50 percent off for 3 months. The per-worker fee is charged only for workers actually paid that month. Extra states cost $12 a month each on Full Service, and a Time and Attendance add-on costs $6 a month plus $2 per employee.
Both plans include unlimited payrolls, free bank pay, a free employee portal, auto payroll, and contractor payments inside payroll. One worker can hold up to 25 pay rates, which covers a tech on installs, repairs and callouts at different rates in one week. The split between the plans is tax filing: Basic does not file your payroll taxes, so you file and pay them yourself, while Full Service files and pays federal, state and local payroll taxes, handles year-end filings at no extra fee, and carries a tax filing guarantee that covers penalties and interest if Patriot makes a filing error.
The honest limit is the filing line itself. Basic at $17 a month is only honest for an owner who will file taxes on time every quarter. For most contractors, Full Service at $37 a month plus $5 per worker is the real price, and it is still the cheapest filed-tax option here.
Best for: a small crew that wants the lowest honest monthly bill with tax filing done for them. Skip it if: you want time tracking, hiring tools or HR advice in the same plan.
A note on Rippling: strong, but priced by quote only
Rippling is named here only because contractors often meet it in search results. It combines payroll, HR and IT in one system for a larger crew. It publishes no prices on its pricing page, so no monthly figure can be printed or compared here. A contractor who wants a Rippling number must go through its sales process, and should judge that quote against the printed prices above.
Worked cost: what a crew really pays each month
Here is the monthly list price for a crew of 5 W-2 staff, then 10, before tax. Patriot Full Service costs $62 a month for 5 staff and $87 for 10. Square Payroll costs $65 a month for 5 and $95 for 10. Gusto Simple costs $79 a month for 5 and $109 for 10, while Gusto Plus costs $140 for 5 and $200 for 10. QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs $82.50 a month for 5 and $115 for 10, before accounting. Patriot Basic costs $37 a month for 5 staff, but it files no taxes.
Year one shows the same order. Patriot Full Service runs $744 a year for 5 staff, Square Payroll runs $780, Gusto Simple runs $948, and QuickBooks Workforce Payroll runs $990 before accounting. The gap between the cheapest and the dearest is about $20 a month, which is small next to one missed tax filing. Pick on fit first, and let the $20 a month break ties.
Seasonal crews should run the quiet-month math too. Square and Patriot charge per person paid, so a month with only 2 staff costs far less than a full month, and Square lets you pause free in the off-season. Gusto bills contractors only in months they are paid, while the QuickBooks accounting subscription beside payroll keeps billing all year. Pair the payroll pick with our best invoicing software for plumbers guide, so the pay run and the customer invoice stay in step.
Which one fits a 1 to 5 person crew
Square Payroll, and the reason is the seasonal shape of a small crew. At $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, a 3-person crew pays $53 a month in a full month and less in a quiet one. Patriot Full Service is the budget alternative at $52 a month for a 3-person crew with tax filing done for you. Pick Square if the crew is hourly and seasonal, and pick Patriot if the lowest filed-tax bill matters most.
Which one fits a 6 to 20 person crew with subs
Gusto Plus, with Square as the price check. At $80 a month plus $12 per person, a 10-person crew pays $200 a month, but it is the only tier that holds multi-state payroll, time tracking, scheduling and hiring tools together, and contractors cost nothing in months they are not paid. A crew that stays in one state and does not hire often should stay on Square at $95 a month for 10 staff, or Patriot Full Service at $87.
Honest limits of this guide
- This guide is based on the vendors official pricing pages, checked on 8 November 2026. Our trial testing is still to come.
- None of the four tools here is contractor specific payroll software. None names job costing, prevailing-wage tracking or certified payroll reporting on its pricing page, so a crew that needs those features should test for them in the trial.
- Payroll tax rules, worker classification rules and prevailing-wage rules change by state and by job. Confirm tax and compliance details with your accountant before you rely on any tool here.
- QuickBooks payroll is sold with a QuickBooks Online accounting plan, so the $50 a month headline is not the whole bill for a new buyer. Patriot Basic files no taxes, and QuickBooks Workforce Payroll does not file local taxes.
- Prices quoted are list prices before tax, and vendors here run introductory promotions.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best payroll software for a small contractor?
For most small contractors, Square Payroll at 35 dollars a month plus 6 dollars per person paid is the best pick, because it includes overtime calculations, multistate payroll, unlimited pay runs and a free seasonal pause at the lowest full-service price here. Patriot Full Service at 37 dollars a month plus 5 dollars per worker paid is the budget pick for a crew that wants tax filing done for them at the lowest monthly cost.
How much does payroll software cost for a small contracting crew?
For a crew of 5 W-2 staff, monthly list prices run from 62 dollars on Patriot Full Service and 65 dollars on Square Payroll, through 79 dollars on Gusto Simple and 82 dollars and 50 cents on QuickBooks Workforce Payroll, before any accounting subscription. For 10 staff the same four run 87, 95, 109 and 115 dollars a month.
Can payroll software handle overtime and 1099 subcontractors together?
Yes, with the right plan. Square Payroll lists overtime calculations and multiple pay rates on its full-service plan, and its contractor-only plan is 6 dollars per person paid. Gusto charges contractors only in months they are paid. Patriot lets you pay contractors inside payroll on both plans, and QuickBooks offers a contractor-only option at 15 dollars for 20 contractors plus 2 dollars per extra contractor.
Do I still need an accountant if I use payroll software?
Yes. Payroll software calculates, files and pays payroll taxes for you on full-service plans, but it does not replace professional advice on worker classification, prevailing-wage rules, state registration or year-end planning. Confirm tax and compliance details with your accountant.
Prices and plan details verified on the official pricing pages of Gusto, QuickBooks, Square and Patriot Software on 8 November 2026. Standard list prices are used throughout, except where a current promotion is named as such.
Related reading: our best software for plumbing businesses roundup, our best scheduling software for plumbers guide, and our best invoicing software for plumbers guide.
